CoinSite Home
Click Here for Coin Gallery of Boca Raton
 
      
Looking for something specific? 

Any word All the words Exact phrase

The Coin Doc's Answers

Archive # 51     Press Ctrl+F to Search This Page

Return to the Coin Doc's Answer Archive Menu

From: "Ray"rayu@worldnet.att.net
Subject: Proof coins
--------------------------------------------------------------
I read in a coin book that a Lincoln cent "1990 proof...without the S" is a somewhat rare coin. Is this true? What does 1990 proof...without the S mean,  does it mean an ordinary 1990 Lincoln cent without the letter "D" or "S" under the date? Any info would be appreciated. Thank you for your time.

Proof coins are specially made coins struck with specially prepared dies and blanks.  The coins are struck twice or more and are carefully handled one at a time. They exhibit mirror fields and often, frosted devices (the design elements). Proof coins are not designed to be spent, though they could be as the designs are identical to their standard circulating cousins though in higher relief.

 Proof coins are sold to collectors in sets of proof examples of all the circulating coins of that year. Currently, only proofs are struck at the San Francisco Mint. In prior years the mint mark was added with a punch that was supplied by the Philadelphia Mint and the mint mark was stamped into each die individually. (Mint marks are now part of the finished die).

In 1990 a proof die failed to receive the "S" mint punch and proof coins struck with that die are missing the mint mark. Examples of this error currently bring approximately $1,000.  For further reading, see the article Observations on Proof Coinage in the articles selection on CoinSite.


Comments:        I think the site is an excellent resource for teachers. The information is very complete.
Name:        James Zarrillo
Email Address:   jzarrill@csuhayward.edu
-------------------------------------------------------
Question:        I am a college professor who at California State University, Hayward. I work with students who will become elementary school teachers. I was visiting a school today, and a fourth grade asked me the following question, "Why is the dime so small? The penny and nickel are both larger than the dime, but the dime is worth more. How come?

The United States used to have an intrinsic monetary system that relied on circulating precious metal coins for commerce.  Coins were "the money". The United States really didn't have a national paper money system until 1861 and that was controversial because they were "Legal Tender" notes, not redeemable for coins. This fiat money was one way the United States raised funds to carry on the Civil War. Paper Money redeemable for gold and silver coins were restored after the war but the paper was only a receipt for coins.

For money to be intrinsic, a dime had to have virtually 10 cents worth of silver, a quarter had to have virtually 25 cents worth of silver,etc. In the early days of the country the precious metal content of U.S. gold and silver coins was too high in relationship to precious metal prices in Europe and massive amounts of coins were melted, sold in Europe and resold back to the United States. The U.S. reduced the precious metal content in 1834 and then in silver coins in 1853 and then was able to keep coins in circulation. Half dimes, dimes, quarters, half dollars and dollars were struck in .900 fine silver and their value, size and weight were proportional (less a small amount of seigniorige to help defray the Mint's cost of producing the coin).

Practical considerations demanded a low value token coinage in order to make change.  The first copper cents were as almost as large as current day half dollars. This was an attempt to make that coin intrinsic  (one cent worth of copper).  It eventually became impractical to use such a coin in everyday transactions and that coin was tokenized and reduced by 1857 to the size we see the cent today. Token coinage was not directly redeemable for precious metal coins and therefore not legal tender.  For example, a 19th century bank might refuse to change 25 cent coins into a silver quarter)

The copper-nickel 5 cent was introduced as a token coinage in 1866 as was made larger for practical reasons.  Though tiny, silver half dimes continued to be produced until 1873 the larger copper-nickel coin was easier to handle and less likely to be lost. (Note that only precious metal coins had reeded edges.  Base metal coins had plain edges)

Though base metal coinage was not legal tender, It was vital to help complete transactions.  The two major 19th century coin shortages, in the 1830's and in the 1860's, virtually brought commerce to its knees due the dearth of small change.  A cottage industry developed during this period making small change in the form of tens of thousands of "good fors" and "advertising tokens" Click here for more information about Hard Times tokens and here for references to "Civil War Tokens"

After 1964 virtually all precious metals were removed from the U.S. coinage system (a lower content, 40% silver half dollars continued to be produced until 1970) and the entire coinage system became tokenized.  Coins were produced that mimicked the look of the old precious metal coins by the clever use of a copper-nickel sandwich with a pure copper core and a reeded edge.  This composition is known as copper-nickel "Clad" coinage.  The cent and nickel remained the same composition as before.  The cent was further debased in 1982 by replacing copper planchets with zinc and then plating them with copper.

Today the size relationship between United States coins still exists but for reasons of tradition only. Also, none of our current coins are legal tender and no one is obligated to accept them as money. Money's definition has changed radically over the years and now only paper money in the form of Federal Reserve Notes are considered legal tender.


Comments:        Great information. I like this site.
Name:        Kevin Hughes
Email Address:   hughesk@kvmo.net
-------------------------------------------------------
Question:        I heard of the supposed error in the state quarter for North Carolina that has Orville laying on the wing of the plane. I searched to look at it, but did not find him on the quarter we have in our set. Is this coin really supposed to have someone on the plane? I only found a single person standing in the foreground and no one on the plane itself. If this is some sort of error, what should we do and how much might it be worth?

This is a striking problem not an error. The figure of Orville Wright is lying prone on lower wing of the plane.  If the figure isn't visible it is most likely due to a weak strike, a  filled die or a strike from a worn die.  For it to be an error, the prone figure would have to be missing from the die.  There are no North Carolina quarter dies that have been reported with such an error.


Name:        Steve Schenk
Email Address:   berkelcoin@aol.com
-------------------------------------------------------
Question:        I am trying to find information on the National Bicentennial Medals that were sold in 1976. What did the Gold, Silver and Bronze Medals sell for? How much Gold or Silver is in them?

I'm not aware of the silver medals but there are two gold medals that feature a image of the Statue of Liberty.  They come in two sizes.  A small medal, about 1/3 troy ounce gold,  and a larger medal, about 2/3 troy ounce gold. 

These pieces seem to be a national secret as they are never listed in lists of coins for sale or show up in any current mint literature that I know of.  I would like to know more about them too.


Name:        Michael zarnowski
Email Address:   onefastmikeandot@aol.com
-------------------------------------------------------
Question:        When purchasing a coin or coins and a dealer or seller tells you he or she has cleaned a coin. Will this degrade the coin and cause it to scratch and or loose its value ? Thanks *** Michael

Disturbing the surface of a coin by cleaning is obvious to trained numismatists and knowledgeable collectors. Yes, it reduces the desirability of the coin and therefore the price.  There are situations where coins have been conserved by removing dirt and encrustations, especially when the coin has been in the ground or under the ocean.  Trained conservators know how to remove foreign material without further damaging the coin.

Note that wear is not considered damage and is the natural progression of a coin.  Though circulated coins are usually less expensive than coins in new condition, they also often have character.  There are many collectors that prefer coins in XF and AU grades because of this factor. Also, uncirculated examples of rare dates are often out of the price range of the majority of collectors so nice, untreated, circulated examples are very desirable.


Comments:        This site is very interesting and helpful
Name:        Jasmin
Email Address:   jmustafovski@sprint.ca
-------------------------------------------------------
Question:        1848 "5 LIRE ITALIANE" diameter  30 mm heads- statue holding a lance in the right hand and she is raising the left hand beneath the statue is the letter "M" letters and symbols can't be printed Question: What do you think the coin is worth and is it rare? Thank you!

You have a 1848 Revolutionary Provisional Government of Lombardy - Venetia 5 Lire. (weight: 25 grams of .900 fine silver (.7234 troy ounce pure).  The coin was issued after the rule of Austria ended over these northern Italian provinces.

The obverse shows  5 LIRE ITALIANE surrounded by a wreath, the legend around, GOVRENO PROVVISORIO DI LOMBARDIA, the date 1848 is below.  The reverse shows a crowned figure of Liberty standing facing her head is turned to her left.  She is wearing a flowing gown, her left hand is raised and her right holds a lance.  The legend, ITALIA LIBERA DIO LO VUOLE,  is around. The mint mark "M" (Milan) is in exergue.

Value depends on type and grade (condition).  Range: $20 - $600+


Name:        Tom Zito
Email Address:   tmbz@hotmail.com
-------------------------------------------------------
Question:        I have read in different magazines & periodicals that it is the coin, and not the holder, that has the value (asked by many people in regards to whether their mint & proof sets were worth more intact or if broken up). What I don't understand though, is why are there different prices for certified coins, even though they are certified as the same grade. Why does PCGS garner higher prices than NGC, even though NGC is the chosen service of the ANA. And NGC gets higher prices than ANACS, which are about the same as IGC, but still higher than PCI. As for SEGS, I rarely see them offered.

Can you explain why in these cases, it is the holder and NOT the coin that creates the prices we see. Thank you.
Tom Zito

 The market you are observing is for holders not coins.


Comments:        Pretty helpful site
Name:        Colin Hutchison
Email Address:   colin_work_2000@yahoo.co.uk
-------------------------------------------------------
Question:        I had a collection of old coins as a kid. Looking at them again the other day, I found one that had always interested me. It is a Mexican coin, dated 1843, silver coloured, pretty large and heavy. It isnÕt clear what the denomination is, but it has the figure 10 D (perhaps 10 dollars?). There is some sort of eagle I think on one side. Any ideas what it is and if it is worth anything? Thanks.

You have a Republic of Mexico 8 Reales (10 decimos). The coin weighs 27.07 grams and is .903 fine silver (.7859 troy ounce pure silver).  The obverse features an Eagle with open wings holding a snake in its mouth, perched on a cactus. A wreath is below.  The legend is, REPUBLICA MEXICANA.  The reverse shows a liberty cap and the word (LIBERTAD) over sun rays.  The legend is arranged to show the denomination - mint mark -date -assayer and the silver content. For example: *8R.Ca.1843.RG.10 Ds.20Gs.

The Mexican Republic continued the Spanish Monetary system until the establishment of a decimal system under the Empire of Maximilian (1864 - 1867)

The value of Republic 8 reales depends on the variety,  mint mark, assayer, date and grade (condition).  Based the above factors the value range is approximately: £7 - £170 (US $10 - $250).


Comments:        I think its a great way to be able to find out your question about coins when its kinda hard to find a good site out there.  :)
Name:        Traci
Email Address:   GratchPassFaery@aol.com
-------------------------------------------------------
Question:        Okay, im not very good with coins, but i found this in my drive way today....and i live in Arlington, WA so i thought it was pretty strange. *Its an old german coin from 1941.  on the back it has the little eagle thing sitting on a swatiska with 1941 at the bottom.  above it, it says something like "Deuitches Reich" on the front it has a bid 5 in the middle and around the edge is has something like "Reich p Fennis B" and two little leaves at the bottom.  its kinda worn and im not much good with german.  its got little ridges on the side like a dime.  its a greyish color, and kinda a light material, not sure what though.  just wondering what it might be worth, if anything.  an answer would be greatly appreciated! :) thanks. traci

One reichspfennig was the lowest denomination in the Third Reich's Monetary system.  This small zinc coin was minted in the hundreds of millions and was an easy souvenir for the U.S. soldiers occupying Germany to acquire after the war ended in 1945.  The coin was minted at seven German Mints and can be identified by the mint mark, a small letter (A,B,D,E,F,G,J).

Average circulated pieces are worth less than U.S. 10 cents.


Name:        Herbert Gopstein
Email Address:   herbgo@home.com
-------------------------------------------------------
Question:        Hello Doc,
I collect military items.  Just today, I bought a small box of WWII knives, medals etc. in a small box.  There was one 20 Lira coin in the box with a picture of Mussolini.  I checked "World Coins" and could not find it.  The obverse, however, is identical to the 1928 10th Anniv. of WWI. I noticed in you response to someone else who appears to have the same coin (30 January) that there is not such a coin.  This is a puzzle since the one I have in front of me looks real enough.  It does not appear played with.  The rim is milled. I would very much appreciate any help you can give me in judging reality and value. Sincerely, Herb Gopstein

This is part of a group of fantasy pieces that were privately made, possibly as a proposal for a future coinage. The coin shows a helmeted Benito Mussolini/Roman Fasces on reverse and celebrates the coming to power of the Fascists in Italy. 

They were struck in 1943 (though they show the dates of 1922-23) and in 20 and 100 Lira denominations and in gold, silver and silvered brass (your coin, I think). There is also a gold coin of Vittorio Emmanuel III (30 grams of gold) in this same group. 

Market value for the silvered brass 20 Lira: less than  US $10. Market value for the silver 20 Lira (17.5 grams) about $20.


 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 


Comments:        it's great, saves alot of frustration, which i now have had for well over an hour.
Name:        miriam howard
Email Address:   MTMP8@aol.com
-------------------------------------------------------
Question:        any worth on a 1911 christian x 20 kronner danmark gold coin? where is it from, any info is helpful, thank-you!!

  Denmark, but it can't be Christian X. He didn't become king until 1913. 1911 20 Kroner show the head of King Frederik VIII (1906-1912).  Gold 20 Kroners from this period contain .2592 troy ounce of gold or a bit more than a quarter ounce so that is the "floor" value (See the CoinSite's Metals page for current gold prices). Examples in About Uncirculated to gem uncirculated grades can bring two or three times the gold value.


From: .Carino@ph.nestle.com
Subject:1707 coin
-------------------------------------------------------
Sir/Madam I would like to ask question to the coin doc about my coin with wordings in front of the coin which says FRID.D.G.REX BORUSS.EL.BR and on the reverse side SVVM CVIQVE 1707 C-S-. My question is what country this coin belong and how much does it worth? Thank you.
Fermin S. Cariño Jr.
Nestlé Philippines, Inc.

1707 Prussia, Thaler (I'm guessing the denomination since you didn't provide a design description or size).

Obverse: Bust of King Friedrich I of Prussia (1701-1713) surrounded by the abbreviated Latin legend, FRID.D.G.REX BORUSS.EL.BR (Friedrich, By the grace of G-d, King and Elector of Brandenburg). The reverse shows a crowned FR monogram at center and order chain around with the medal at bottom bisecting the date 1707. The legend around is SVVM CVIQVE suum cuique (Let each have his own).

Value depends on authenticity, (lots of fakes exist) and grade (condition). Approximate value range for genuine examples: $200 - $6,000.


Comments:        Love the site!!
Name:        Cutler Whitman
Email Address:   cwhitman@boxingdigest.com
-------------------------------------------------------
Question:        Dear Doc, I have found a coin that has a date of 1933.  It has a ship on one side and a shield on the other with the value printed:  5$00 on the bottom. Any thoughts would be great.

You have a 1933 Portugal 5 escudos.  The"$" is used here like Americans use a decimal point and Europeans used a ",".  In fact, that was the original use for the "$" sign.  The coin weighs 7 grams and is struck on .650 fine silver blanks (.1463 troy ounce pure).  Almost seven million were struck in 1933.  Market value ranges from the bullion value to about $15 in uncirculated grades.


Name:        D. Dye
Email Address:   dye@semo.net
 -------------------------------------------------------
Question:        I have a 1961 Lincoln Penny that has a band around the outside edge.  This band does not appear to be altered or added to this coin.  Any information would be welcome.

There is no mechanism in a coin press to add a "band" around the edge of a coin.  It is possible to have deep edge because of high striking pressure. Also, it is possible for a coin to get stuck to the obverse (upper) die and to strike other coins with the reverse (brockage).  The "stuck" coin's edge increases in size until the coin falls off.  I once saw an Eisenhower dollar at the private museum at the Denver Mint that could pass for a small cup. Coins victim to this error have deformed reverses.

Coins are often used in advertising media and are encased in holders. The maker often will solder a band around a cent as a frame to hold the coin in place in a key ring or other advertising holder.

If you believe that your coin is a genuine mint error, you can show the coin to a coin dealer or send it to the American Numismatic Association for authentication (see their link on the CoinSite Links page ).


From: "Yunier Hernandez Torres" yunior@ghost.matcom.uh.cu subject: 1943 copper cent
--------------------------------------------------------------
I am sorry for not writing you along this days, but i got in trouble with my email and  I could not send any message out of cuba but now my email is back. I am sending you an attachment with a scan of a 1943 copper cent for you to see it an tell me what you think of it. Write me and tell me your impression about its authenticity, Greetings, Yunior.

This looks like a altered 1948 cent.  The spacing looks too wide between the "4" and the "3" and the "3" is the wrong shape. Note that the date is a single punch, that is, the digits are not stamped separately into the die. Sorry, no Cuban cigar!

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Comments:        From what I've seen, I'm very impressed. Name:        Armin Meyer Email Address:   hiplains@imt.net
-------------------------------------------------------
Question:        Hi! 'Can't seem to find the answer to my question-namely, what would be a ballpark estimate of how much I should ask for my complete set of Washington Quarters 1932-2001--all uncirculated and or proof (taken from Uncirculated and/or proof sets. The 1932-1936 coins are uncirculated but one person's MS-60 is another's MS-50 but like I say, what would be a starting figure for a collection like this? (There are 210 coins total) Thanks for your help! Meyer

Since grading is critical and you believe them to be uncirculated, I suggest having the coins graded by a third party grading service (see the CoinSite Links Page for their Web sites. For example the 1932-D alone can vary in price from about $200 - $6,000+.


Comments:        This is an awesome site.....thanks to all who created it. Name:        Cathy Email Address:   Fvance@cyberus.ca
-------------------------------------------------------
Question:        Hi Doc,  I have a 1864 Confederate States of America five-hundred dollar bill that is dated Feb 17th, 1864.  It's in fairly poor condition, but I was wondering what type of value this bill holds.  It was found between the walls of an old house that was being demolished. Thanking you in advance for your time, Sincerely                 Cathy.

This is a scarce type. The note has red underprinting, a confederate seal with an equestrian statue of George Washington below the Confederate flag at left. General "Stonewall" Jackson is at lower right. Low grade but intact examples bring $100-$200.


Comments:        Informative, easy to read, can spend many hours researching!!! Name:        Fredi Branch Email Address:   ammobox@inna.net
-------------------------------------------------------
Question:        Dear Doc,  I have a 1884 Carson City uncirculated silver dollar which I would like to know the value.  It is in a rectangular plastic case which is in a black box with a medium blue lining.  On the inside top of the box are the words "As we approach America's Bicentennial, this historic silver dollar is one of the most valued reminders of our national heritage.  RICHARD NIXON"

The paper inside the box has a blue # printed on the upper right corner which is "83276182".  The 3 paragraphs on the paper describe information about the historic coin, valuable memento, history, etc.  At the very bottom of the paper is printed "United States Government  1972".

Can you tell me what it's worth might be or how I can find out?  I am not familiar with grading and other words I've read about.  I sure would appreciate any information you'd share with me.  I really have learned a lot from your site.  Thanks!  Fredi Branch, Gloucester, VA.

In the early 1960's the U.S. government discovered huge quantities of uncirculated silver dollars in storage.  Many bags of 1,000 were sold at face value. As the price of silver rose substantially over the face value of all silver coins, the sale of dollars was withdrawn. Many souces from collectors to dealers and the general public recommended various schemes in which to sell off the remaining government silver dollars. 

On Dec 31, 1970 President Nixon signed the Bank Holding company Act which included a provision authorizing the General Services Administration to sell the silver dollars.  In 1971 the Treasury turned over the remaining silver dollars to the General Services Administration. They were stored at the Bullion Depository at West Point, New York.

The GSA held five mail-bid sales of Carson City Mint dollars and two fixed price sales of general mixed dollars. They were encapsulated in hard plastic holders with a black background and packaged in a cardboard box as you described.  Prices varied from $20 to about $85.

Of the Carson City dollars, a few lucky recipients received better date Carson City dollars but most received the more common 1883-CC and 1884-CC examples.  The holders hold appeal to some collectors but the value of the coin depends on the actual grade and the reflectivity of the fields (very reflective fields are called proof-like or Deep Mirror).   Approximate value Range for uncirculated 1884-CC Morgan Dollars: $50 - $500. 1884-CC dollars that grade higher than MS65 bring much higher prices.

For information about grading, see the CoinSite FAQ and the article U.S. Coin Grading .


From:JERRY DEGRAFFjerry074@earthlink.net subject: gold coin
-------------------------------------------------------
I have a 1997 walking liberty gold coin. On the back there is an eagle landing in a nest with a Brach in its talon. There is a mother and two babies in the nest.At the bottom it reads 1oz. fine gold 50 dollar. I was wondering if it was worth more than that.                      Thank you

The denomination of $50 on the United States Gold bullion coins called "Eagles" makes it a coin but it has nothing to do with its real value.  Your coin contains one troy ounce of pure gold and its value depends on the price of gold in the market (currently about $260 per ounce).  See the CoinSite Metals Page for current gold price.  Note that the coin usually brings a premium of 5% or more above the bullion price unless the coin has been damaged.


Comments:        This is the only place that I know where I can get the answer to any of my coin questions.  This site is by far the best. Name:        Andrew Wege Email Address:   wegefamily@charter.net
-------------------------------------------------------
Question:        I have a very interesting coin that I would like to know more about.  I have asked a few people about it and all they can tell me is that it is Roman and has a picture of Constantine on it.  The coin is about the size of a penny and it is made out of copper.  On the front the coin has a head of a man facing to the right.  There are words both to the right and left of the head.  To the left in caps it appears to say CONSTHN.  To the right it appears to read TINVSHVS. 

On the reverse of the coin right in the middle is what looks like a wreath.  At the bottom inside part of the wreath it has what looks like a six point star.  To the right and left of the star are X's.  In the very center of the wreath is a dot and written across inside the top of the wreath is the letters VOT.  Underneath the wreath it has the letters SMHA.  I might be reading them upside down though.  It could be VHWS.  Around the outside of the wreath it has something written.  It says DNCONANTINHXHVC.  Anything that you could tell me about this coin like when and where it was made and the value of it would be appreciated.  Any other information that you have would be great also.  Thanks.

You have a bronze Imperial Rome AE3 (about 17 mm in diameter) of Constantine I, The Great (307-337 AD).  There was so much revision of coinage in this period that the names of the many small denomination coins have been lost. Today, numismatists identify these coins by their size and type, AE=bronze 1-4= the size (like shoes, except the larger number means a smaller coin).< /P>

The obverse shows a laureate bust of Emperor Constantine I, the abbreviated Latin legend around is: CONSTANTINVS AVG.  The reverse shows a laurel wreath around VOT. xxx ("votis" or a vow or prayer probably short for something like "votis incendimus aras", that which has been vowed or promised. "I'm going to kick the barbarians out of Rome", one on the top ten list).  The legend around is D.N. CONSTANTINI MAX. AVG. ([so says] Emperor Constantine, the Great).  In exergue (the place under a dividing line on a coin) are letters representing the Mint where the coin was struck, like a Mint Mark on a U.S. coin (yours the Sirmium Mint?).

Bronzes similar to these are often found in large numbers in archaeological digs and find their way into the numismatic market place. After all, small change is a very important part of any monetary system (imagine all the billions of Lincoln cents two thousand years from now).  Approximate value range for average examples $10 - $35.


Comments:        just found your site and think its great to have a site like this on the internet.
Name:        mike
Email Address:   oz1665@home.com
-------------------------------------------------------
Question:        hi doc, i am into metal detecting and do a lot of beach hunting and last weekend i found a walking liberty half 1936 and i noticed on the front, right above where it is stamped "in god we trust" there was another stamp into the coin that reads SALEM ORG have you ever seen a coin with this stamp on it? can you tell me what it means. thanks doc for your help.  mike

Counterstamps on coins is an interesting area of collecting and goes under the heading of Exonumia.  The stamp, of course, has been added by someone to a normal circulating coin.  Advertising, political messages, souvenirs and vending machine test coins are some of the reasons that U.S. coins are sometimes found counterstamped.

See the article Reengraved Cents in the CoinSite FAQ for more examples of this kind of alteration.


Comments:        Great information, I was able to find information about several other coins that I have.
Name:        joy case
Email Address:   ajmcase@starpower.net
-------------------------------------------------------
Question:        I found a small silver coin, about the size of a dime, it has Carolus IIII del gratia, (1793 or 1795), on the front The back has a coat of arms in the middle, with the words Hispan.ET. IND. M .F.M.  There is a small symbol over the top of the first M after IND.  The coin is in pretty good shape, the edges are a little worn, the lettering is still easily readable, except the last number of the date is blurry. Any information would be appreciated.

You have a Spain 1 1793 or 1795 1 real, Madrid Mint, Assayers MF (Manuel de Lamas and Francisco Herrera) under King Charles IV .  Coins similar to these, mostly with new world mint marks, circulated in the United States as legal tender until about 1858 and passed as 12 1/2 cents (called "a bit"). (Very worn pieces were accepted as 10 cents). Value range in average circulated condition $5 - $25.


Comments:        First time visiting, very informative!
Name:        Elaine Flynn
Email Address:   briar_rose7@hotmail.com
-------------------------------------------------------
Question:        Hi-I have an encased giant silver 'medallion' like coin from the Washington Mint, which is approx. 4" in diameter. The front has a picture of a large walking liberty (I'm not sure that's what it's really called, but she looks to be walking to me) with one hand out-stretched and a bouquet of two different things in her other (perhaps wheat and olive branch?).

She appears to be wrapped in an american flag. Directly below her feet is the date "1997". To her lower left is a brilliant sun on the horizon; to her lower right are the words "IN GOD WE TRUST"; the word "LIBERTY" is written across the top. I guess it's signed by the artist, "DUREK" is printed beneath one of her feet. The back has a large eagle in the center, with out-streched wings and a sheild in front of his chest, a branch of some sort (olive?) is in his left foot and directly below that is a small box with "XX" inside, arrows are in his right foot. A banner in his mouth reads "E PLURIBUS UNUM". A downward pointing triangle of 13 stars is above his head as well as the words "UNITED STATES OF AMERICA".

Across the bottom are the words "ONE POUND FINE SILVER .999. The 'ribbed' edging has some sort of small, round 'burn' like spot/sodering mark (perhaps made during the minting process?) at one end, on the other is a smooth area with the serial number "0183" imprinted in it. It looks to be in mint condition, and has a blue velvety case with the picture of a silver eagle and the words "THE WASHINGTON MINT" printed inside the lid. I received it when my grandfather passed away in 1999, and can't find anything out about what exactly it is or how much it is worth...can you help?? Thank You!

The "Washington Mint" is a private mint with no relationship to the United States Mint.  They create promotional items, in this case a enlarged reproduction of a one ounce U.S. silver eagle.  The value of this bullion item is the silver content ( 1 troy pound=12 troy ounces).  See the CoinSite Metals Page for current silver prices in troy ounces.


Name:  Linda Coleman
Email Address:   linda.coleman@revlon.com
-------------------------------------------------------
Question:        What was the error made on the South Carolna state quarters (2000) and the potential value?  We are not sure what we are looking for.

The pilot, Orville Wright, lying prone on the wing. There is no mint error, just some coins are struck better or worse than others making the pilot more or less visible. An error would be if the pilot was missing on some working dies. (Ah! The "no Orville" variety).


Name:        AnnMarie Bee
Email Address:   survivor1@myself.com
-------------------------------------------------------
Question:        Yes, I read your information regarding the two headed coins. Are you saying that this error was NEVER made at the mint? A friend has found a 2 headed 1982 quarter in good to fair condition and cannot find any evidence of tampering. He has had it looked at with a magnifying glass and other methods. Is it possible that this is real and if so how do you determine the value? Thank you

I usually don't respond to question about 2 headed or 2 tailed coins as this subject is covered in detail on Coinsite.  Yes, this error was NEVER made at the mint, at least not yet, (ok, there was a crude fabrication of two obverse dies by a mint employee on a copper-nickel Indian cent in 1859). The reason that this hasn't happened has much to do with how obverse and reverse dies are manufactured.

A diagnostic is to simply weigh the coin. A standard clad quarter weighs 5.67 grams.  Any deviation from this weight would indicate that the coin was altered. If you find that the coin weighs this exact weight, congratulations, you are now wealthy and have in your possession the worlds only known United States two headed quarter.

Now, you need to have it certified.  You can have this done at the American Numismatic Association in Colorado Springs.  Though the cost is nominal (about $25), I would hand carry the coin to them and wait for the certification.  After certification you might want to hire Brinks or some other security organization to transport the coin to a safe location. Any major auction house would be happy to arrange the sale of the coin.

After the coin is sold (ahem!), remember the Coin Doc!

Good luck

Browse more of the COIN DOC's Answer Archives 

Ask the Coin Doc - Copyright © 1997-2007 Robert S. Koppelman, Stan Klein & ROKO Design Group, Inc. All rights reserved.

CoinSite Home

Copyright 1997-2008 ROKO Design Group, Inc. All rights reserved.